NYC schools chancellor violated free speech rights of parent activist who called out ‘Jew hatred’: judge.-davinci

Maud Maron responds to political content in New York City schools in December 2022

1 second of 38 secondsVolume 0%

A New York City parent activist booted from her education post after calling out “Jew hatred” should be reinstated, a federal judge ruled — finding Schools Chancellor David Banks likely violated her free speech rights by ousting her.

Banks removed Maud Maron from Community Education Council 2 in June after the Manhattan mom was quoted in a Post article slamming an anonymous editorial in the Stuyvesant HS student newspaper that accused Israel of genocide.

But Maron’s removal “violated the first amendment because it discriminates based on viewpoint,” Brooklyn federal court Judge Diane Gujarati wrote in a hard-hitting ruling this week.

Maud Maron speaking at the Moms for Liberty National Summit at the JW Marriott Washington in Washington, DC.

A federal judge ruled that Maud Maron should be reinstated to her education post after she was booted for calling out “Jew hatred.” ZUMAPRESS.com

The First Amendment is mentioned 39 times and the word “unconstitutional” is cited 18 times in the judge’s 54-page decision granting Maron’s request for a preliminary injunction halting her ouster.

“Plaintiff Maron is entitled to reinstatement… Plaintiff Maron should be reinstated immediately to her elected position on CEC 2 for the pendency of this action,” Gujarati wrote.

“I’m thrilled our court system is holding up well to the assault on free speech,” Maron told The Post on Wednesday, adding she was “elated” and “absolutely thrilled” with Gujarati’s Sept. 3 ruling.

Maron, who has claimed she’s a victim of cancel culture, had already drawn the ire of LGBT activists and liberals in the school system for her opposition to allowing biological males who identify as transgender to compete against females in competitive sports.

Then she called out the full-page editorial published in the February issue of the Stuyvesant student paper for whitewashing Hamas’ depraved Oct. 7, 2023 massacre while accusing Israel of atrocities, including apartheid and ethnic cleansing.

“The byline should read coward instead of anonymous. If you are going to repeat revolting Hamas propaganda and transcribe your ignorance and Jew hatred, put your name to it,” Maron, a Stuyvesant parent who also serves on the school leadership team, said then.

“Principal [Seung] Yu should address the school and explain to Jewish students why this factually inaccurate bile was published on the school paper anonymously.”

Photo of Chancellor of New York City Public Schools David C. Banks

Chancellor of New York City Public Schools David C. Banks removed Maron from Community Education Council 2 in June after she was quoted in a Post article slamming an anonymous editorial in the Stuyvesant HS student newspaper. NYC Public Schools

Banks claimed Maron’s criticism constituted “verbal abuse” and aggressive speech in violation of the code of conduct/anti-discrimination/anti-harassment policy.

But Gujarati suggested the chancellor’s decision was a head-scratcher because Maron did not even know who the editorial’s anonymous author was and the writer was not identified.

“Notably, plaintiff Maron’s comments did not identify the editorial’s author and plaintiff Maron declares that she did not know the author’s identity, or whether it was a student, a staff member or other person,” the judge wrote.

Gujarati also found that the Department of Education appeared to violate Maron’s free speech rights because it objected to her comments.

“Plaintiffs have shown a clear and substantial likelihood of establishing that the challenged portion of Section II(D) [the regulation] facially violates the First Amendment,” the decision said.

Stuyvesant High School

Maron slammed the newspaper that accused Israel of genocide, though her being removed from her post “violated the first amendment because it discriminates based on viewpoint,” said Brooklyn federal court Judge Diane Gujarati. Helayne Seidman

“Plaintiffs Have Shown a Clear and Substantial Likelihood of Establishing that the Challenged Portions of Regulation D-210 are Unconstitutional,” the judge added.

Gujarati said Maron is likely prevail in her final ruling because “securing first amendment rights is in the public interest.”

The judge also barred Community Education Council 14 in Brooklyn from restricting access to its social media accounts and meetings, in violation of the law. The left-wing board’s leadership has blocked pro-Israel voices from participating in meetings.

The ruling did not reinstate the Taijh Sutton, the controversial president of CEC 14, who also was removed by the chancellor for silencing others.

In response, Banks’ spokesman Nathaniel Styer said, “Creating positive and supportive environments for our school communities is a priority for New York City Public Schools, and we are disappointed by a ruling that limits our ability to protect students from harmful conduct by parent leaders.”

But Styer also said that prior to the court’s ruling, Banks and the DOE began “reviewing the applicable chancellor’s regulation and are preparing to propose revisions and initiate our public engagement process.”

“We will also continue to support CEC 14 towards complying with its legal requirements. We will continue to review the ruling for next steps,” the rep said.

Related Posts

Br3aking: Feds v3rify that D!ddy s0ld a Bey0ncé video for $20 million. Did D!ddy sm3ar it with baby o!l?-davinci

A shocking turn in the entertainment world has shaken social media and public opinion. It has been confirmed that Beyoncé’s graphic video, despite previous warnings about its…

It was r3vealed that D!ddy had f0rced Jenn!fer L0pez to d0 it with a 13-year-old girl.-davinci

The entertainment world has been thrust back into the spotlight with new allegations against music mogul Sean “Diddy” Combs. The new allegations, which involve claims of sexual…

Br3aking: D!ddy’s f0rmer b0dyguard has shar3d new pictures of his p@rty at the Org!e.-davinci

In a shocking revelation, Sean “Diddy” Combs’ former security guard has leaked a series of explosive videos that reveal the secrets of the music mogul’s infamous parties….

Kany3 W3st afirma que L3Bron Jam3s vendió su alma a D!ddy a cambio de un salario de 100 millones de dólares.–davinci

En un mundo en el que las celebridades suelen ser el centro de la controversia, pocos han provocado tanto debate como Kanye West. Conocido por su carácter…

Última hora: Los federales confirman que D!ddy vendió un video de Beyoncé por 20 millones de dólares. ¿D!ddy lo manchó con aceite de bebé?-davinci

Un giro impactante en el mundo del espectáculo ha sacudido las redes sociales y la opinión pública. Se ha confirmado que el vídeo de Beyoncé, a pesar…

N3W: Andr3 3000 publica un video de D!ddy retozando con Khl0e Kardash!an y Kyl!e J3nner en fiestas.-davinci

El reciente revuelo en torno a Andre 3000, Diddy y la familia Kardashian ha suscitado serias controversias que ahondan en el lado oculto de Hollywood. Andre, conocido…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *